The ultimate debate seed vs seedling does it any difference and and introduction to grafting

Share Tweet

Starting a garden can be a rewarding and enjoyable experience, but the decision of whether to start from seed or seedlings can be a difficult one. Both methods have their own benefits and drawbacks, and the best option for you will depend on your gardening goals, experience, and the specific plants you want to grow. In this article, we will explore the differences between starting a garden from seed and seedlings, and the pros and cons of each method. We will look at factors such as cost, time, and the varieties of plants available, as well as the technical aspects such as germination, care and maintenance. Whether you’re an experienced gardener or new to the hobby, this article will provide a comprehensive guide to help you make an informed decision and start your own successful garden.

Whether it’s better to grow from a seedling or from a seed depends on the specific plant and your gardening goals. Both methods have their own benefits and drawbacks.

Growing from seed:

Advantages: Growing from seed is often less expensive than buying seedlings, and it allows you to choose from a wider variety of plants. It can also be more satisfying to watch a plant grow from a seed to maturity.
Disadvantages: Growing from seed takes more time, as seedlings need to be started indoors and may take several weeks to germinate. Seedlings are also more delicate and require more care than established plants.
Great selections of seeds are available at your local hardware store and now, even Amazon.

Growing from seedlings:

Advantages: Buying seedlings or young plants is often quicker than growing from seed, as the seedling is already established and ready to be transplanted into your garden. Seedlings are also less delicate than plants grown from seed and can withstand more environmental stress.
Disadvantages: Buying seedlings can be more expensive than growing from seed, and the variety of plants available may be more limited.
Numerous selections of seedlings are available at your local hardware or garden store, for Home Depot, we find it best to check out there selections online first.

Ultimately, the best method for you will depend on your gardening goals, experience, and the specific plants you want to grow. Some plants are easy to grow from seed and do not require much attention, while others might be hard to germinate and grow, in this case, seedlings can be a more convenient option.

What garden plants grow best from seed?

Many plants can be grown from seed, but some are more suited to this method than others. Here are a few examples of plants that grow well from seed:

Annual flowers: Many annual flowers such as marigold, zinnia, and sunflowers are easy to grow from seed. They germinate quickly and can be sown directly in the garden.
Vegetables: Many vegetables such as beans, cucumbers, squash, and tomatoes can be grown from seed. They are often less expensive to grow from seed than to buy seedlings.
Herbs: Many herbs such as basil, dill, and parsley can be grown from seed. They germinate quickly and can be sown directly in the garden.
Perennials: Some perennial plants such as coneflowers, coreopsis, and black-eyed susans can be grown from seed. They may take longer to germinate and establish, but once they are established, they will come back year after year.
Trees and shrubs: Some trees and shrubs such as acorns, chestnuts, and pinecones can be grown from seed. They take longer to germinate and establish, but once they are established, they will grow into full-sized trees or shrubs.

It’s important to note that not all plants are suitable for growing from seed, some plants have specific germination requirements and others may not come true to seed and will not produce plants like the parent plant, in this case, it’s better to use vegetative propagation methods such as cuttings, grafting, or layering.

Generally, how much cheaper is it to buy seeds than seedlings?

Generally, buying seeds is less expensive than buying seedlings. The cost of seed packets is usually less than the cost of seedlings, which are already established young plants. The cost difference can vary widely depending on the specific plant, the quantity of seeds in the packet, and where you purchase the seeds or seedlings.

For example, a seed packet for a common vegetable like tomatoes might cost around $3-$4 for around 20-50 seeds, whereas a seedling of the same vegetable might cost around $2-$5 for a single plant.

In general, if you are planning to grow a large number of plants, buying seeds can be significantly cheaper than buying seedlings. However, if you are only growing a few plants, the cost difference may be less significant.

It’s worth noting that seed packets usually have a larger quantity of seeds than seedlings and will give you the opportunity to grow more plants with the same amount of money spent. It’s also important to remember that when you grow your plants from seeds, you have a wider variety of options to choose from and also it can be a more satisfying experience.

Seedling Care

Seedling care is the process of nurturing and caring for young plants that have germinated from seed and have reached the seedling stage. It is an important step in the process of growing plants from seed, as seedlings are delicate and require special attention to ensure they develop into healthy mature plants. Here are some key aspects of seedling care that you should consider:

Light: Seedlings need bright, indirect light to grow strong and healthy. They should be placed in a sunny location or under grow lights, but not in direct sunlight as this can cause the seedlings to become too hot and dry out.
Water: Seedlings need to be kept consistently moist, but not waterlogged. They should be watered gently when the soil surface feels dry to the touch. Overwatering can lead to mold, mildew, and root rot, while underwatering can cause the seedlings to wilt and die.
Temperature: Seedlings prefer warm temperatures between 60-75°F (15-24°C). If the temperature is too cold, the seedlings will not germinate or grow, if too hot the seedlings will dry out.
Fertilizer: Seedlings need a balanced fertilizer that is high in phosphorus and potassium to promote healthy root growth and flower production. Fertilizing seedlings too early or with too much fertilizer can cause damage to the young plants.
Transplanting: Seedlings should be transplanted into larger pots or into the ground when they have several true leaves and are large enough to handle. Transplanting seedlings too early can cause damage to the roots and set the plant back.
Pest and disease control: Seedlings are particularly susceptible to pests and diseases, it’s important to keep an eye out for any signs of infestation or infection and take action accordingly.
Monitoring: Keep a close eye on your seedlings and monitor their growth, if they are not growing or showing signs of stress, take steps to address the issue.

Seedling care can be time-consuming, but it is an essential step in the process of growing plants from seed. By providing your seedlings with the right care and conditions, you can ensure that they develop into healthy mature plants that are ready for transplanting into the garden.

Timing- which is produces faster yields? (It depends)

The time it takes for a seed to germinate and grow into a seedling can vary depending on the specific plant and the conditions under which it is grown. Generally, it takes longer to grow a plant from seed than from seedlings.

When growing from seed, you will need to factor in the time it takes for the seed to germinate, which can range from a few days to several weeks. Once the seed has germinated, it will take several weeks for the seedling to grow large enough to be transplanted into the garden or a larger pot. The whole process from seed to seedling can take anywhere from 4 to 12 weeks or more, depending on the species of the plant.

On the other hand, when growing from seedlings, you can skip the germination phase, and the seedling is already established and ready to be transplanted into the garden or a larger pot. This process can take anywhere from a few days to a few weeks, depending on the size of the seedling and the conditions under which it is grown.

It’s important to note that some seeds can be directly sown in the garden, this means that the seed is planted directly in the soil, and the seedling will grow in place. This can save time and effort, but it also depends on the specific plant and the climate conditions.

The time required for seeds to grow into seedlings can vary depending on the specific plant, the growing conditions, and the stage of growth. Here are some general guidelines for the time frame for seed to seedling growth:

Germination: The time it takes for a seed to germinate, or sprout, can vary depending on the plant, but it typically takes between 5-10 days for most seeds to germinate. Some seeds, like those of some vegetables, can germinate in as little as 3 days, while others, like some perennials or trees, can take several weeks to germinate.
Seedling Stage: Once the seed has germinated, it enters the seedling stage. The time it takes for a seedling to reach the transplantable stage can vary depending on the plant, but it is usually between 4-6 weeks. For example, tomatoes seedlings can be ready to transplant in 6-8 weeks, while others like cucumbers can be ready in 4-5 weeks.
Maturity: After being transplanted, the time it takes for a seedling to reach maturity can also vary depending on the plant. For example, most annuals will reach maturity in one growing season, while perennials and trees can take several years.

What about oranges and grapefruits, can citrus fruits actually be grown from seeds?

Citrus fruits can be grown from seeds, but the resulting trees will not produce fruit identical to the parent fruit. Citrus fruits are propagated through a process called grafting, where a shoot from a mature tree is joined to the rootstock of a young tree. This is done because citrus trees grown from seed will not produce fruit that is true to the parent. The seedling will likely produce a different fruit, with different characteristics.

Grafting has several advantages, such as the ability to control the size and shape of the tree, the ability to produce fruit in a shorter time period, and the ability to produce fruit that is true to the parent.

That being said, you can grow citrus trees from seed as a fun experiment or for ornamental purposes, but if you want fruit that is identical to the parent, it’s best to buy a grafted tree. Some citrus fruits such as oranges and lemons can be grown from seed, but it’s important to keep in mind that they may take longer to fruit, and the fruit will be different from the parent.

Grafting is a method of plant propagation in which a shoot from a mature tree (the scion) is joined to the rootstock of a young tree. This technique has been used for centuries to propagate fruit trees, nut trees and ornamental trees. Here are some pros and cons of grafting:

Pros:

Control over the fruit variety: By grafting different varieties of fruit trees, you can have control over the variety of fruit that you want to grow. This is particularly useful for fruit trees such as apples, pears, and peaches, where there are many different varieties available.
Improved fruit quality: Grafting can improve the fruit quality by selecting the best rootstock for the fruit variety and location.
Faster fruiting: Grafted trees can fruit much faster than seed-grown trees, as the scion is already mature and able to produce fruit.
Disease resistance: By selecting rootstock that is resistant to certain diseases and pests, grafting can improve the tree’s overall health and longevity.
Control over tree size: Grafting can control the size of the tree, by selecting dwarf or semi-dwarf rootstock, which can be beneficial for small gardens or orchards.

Cons:

Cost: Grafting can be more expensive than growing a tree from seed. The cost of the scion and the rootstock, as well as the labor involved, can make it more expensive than growing a tree from seed.
Limited genetic diversity: Grafting limits the genetic diversity of the tree population, as all the trees will be genetically identical to the scion.
Dependence on the rootstock: The health and productivity of the tree will depend on the rootstock, if the rootstock is not suitable for the location or is infected by pests or diseases, the tree will not perform well.
Limited to specific plants: Grafting is not suitable for all plants, and not all plants can be grafted.

In general, grafting is a useful method of plant propagation, with many advantages and some limitations, that can be used to improve the quality and productivity of fruit trees, nut trees and ornamental trees. It’s important to consider your goals, budget and experience before deciding whether to use grafting for your plants.